Muzzling the Prophetic – Do We Keep on Smiling and Say Nothing?

Prophets are referenced 480 times in the scripture, and pastors only once. 480 individuals who dared to speak, “Thus says the Lord,” challenging kings, comforting the afflicted, and steering the people back to the heart of God. Yet, in the contemporary Christian landscape, dominated by a pastoral culture often fixated on stability and maintenance, the vibrant, often disruptive, voice of the prophet is too often relegated to the periphery, a dusty relic of a bygone era. This marginalization is not merely an oversight; it is a perilous silencing, a strategic weakening of the very body of Christ, perpetrated by insecure, selfish leaders, and a direct contradiction of the diverse gifts Christ himself bestowed upon his Church in Ephesians 4:11.

Pastors often claim that the prophetic is a disruptive influence, thus maintaining a convenient justification for their sidelining. The true issue is not the perceived ego of the prophetic but the ingrained discomfort of a pastoral paradigm that prioritizes the predictable over the potentially disruptive, the comforting over the confronting. This is a culture that often confuses the gentle shepherd’s staff with a mandate to silence the piercing cry of the watchman on the wall.

Let us be unequivocally clear: prophetic office is not an antiquated footnote in biblical history. It is a vital, living function within the body of Christ, as essential today as it was in the courts of Israel or the nascent churches of the New Testament. The Holy Spirit, the very breath of God, has not ceased to anoint individuals to speak His heart, to reveal His secrets, and to call His people to radical obedience. To suggest otherwise is to diminish the sovereignty of God and to confine the boundless dynamism of the Spirit within the comfortable confines of human control.

The subtle, and sometimes not-so-subtle, dismissal of the modern prophet manifests in various ways. It is seen in the suspicion cast upon those who claim to hear directly from God, labeled as “unbalanced” or “divisive.” It is evident in the institutional structures that prioritize theological training and pastoral experience while often lacking robust avenues for the identification, development, and healthy integration of prophetic gifts. It echoes in the sermons that focus primarily on personal growth and relational harmony, often at the expense of a bold, societal critique rooted in biblical justice.

This pastoral myopia stems, in part, from a fear of the uncontrolled. Prophetic utterances can be uncomfortable. They can challenge the status quo, expose hypocrisy, and demand uncomfortable change. During the first 20 years of my ministry, I was a pastor and invited prophets to come minister to the people. In all those encounters, I often had to clean up a mess afterward, but I valued the prophetic and new that it came with a cost. In a world, and indeed within churches, that often prizes order and avoids conflict, the prophet, with their inconvenient truths and urgent calls to repentance, can feel like a disruptive force. It is easier, safer, to manage the flock through established programs and predictable patterns than to navigate the sometimes-turbulent waters stirred by a genuine word from the Lord.

Furthermore, the modern church has often fallen prey to a consumeristic model, where congregants are seen as customers to be pleased rather than a flock to be challenged and matured. The seeker-sensitive, user-friendly model for pastoral ministry that dominates the church today is one of the most acidic, destructive influences found among God’s people. The prophet, with their unwavering commitment to God’s agenda rather than human preferences, can be a stark and unwelcome contrast to this paradigm. Their message may not always be palatable, their pronouncements may not always be encouraging in a feel-good sense, but they are always, when authentic, ultimately for the good of God’s people, leading them towards truth and genuine transformation.

The marginalization of the prophet also reveals a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of God himself. He is not merely a God of comfort and peace, though He is certainly both. He is also a God of justice, a God who speaks truth to power, a God who disrupts complacency. The prophetic voice in Scripture consistently reflects this multifaceted nature of God, calling out injustice, warning against idolatry, and urging a return to covenant faithfulness. To silence the prophetic voice today is to silence a crucial aspect of God’s communication with His people. To reject the prophetic is to craft a religious opiate that lulls people to sleep when they should be arming for war. 

The consequences of this prophetic deficit are profound. Without the sharp edge of prophetic insight, the church risks becoming complacent, inward-focused, and disconnected from the urgent realities of the world around it. We become adept at tending our own gardens while ignoring the fires raging in the neighboring fields. We cultivate personal piety while remaining silent in the face of systemic injustice. We preach comfortable platitudes while the world cries out for a word of truth and hope rooted in divine revelation.

The gifts listed in Ephesians 4:11 are not a hierarchy of importance but a symphony of interdependent ministries, each vital for the health and growth of the body of Christ. Apostles provide foundational leadership and expansion, prophets offer divine insight and correction, evangelists proclaim the good news, and pastors and teachers nurture and equip the saints. To elevate one at the expense of another is to create a lopsided and ultimately weakened body. Imagine an orchestra where the string section dominates and the brass instruments are muted – the richness and power of the music are undeniably diminished. Similarly, a church that silences its prophets operates with a diminished capacity to hear and respond to the fullness of God’s will.

The defense of the prophetic office in the modern day is not a call for chaos. It is a plea for discernment, for a renewed appreciation for the genuine prophetic voice that aligns with Scripture, edifies the church, and challenges the world. It requires a pastoral culture that is mature enough to embrace the discomfort of prophetic confrontation alongside the comfort of pastoral care. It necessitates the development of structures within our churches that can identify, nurture, and hold accountable those with genuine prophetic gifts.

We desperately need the modern-day prophets. We need those who can see beyond the surface, who can discern the subtle currents of the Spirit, and who dare to speak truth to power, both within and outside the church. We need voices that will call us back to biblical justice, challenge our comfortable assumptions, and remind us of the urgent need for repentance and radical obedience. We need the uncomfortable truths that can shake us out of our complacency and propel us into God’s intended future.

The silence surrounding the prophetic in many of our churches is a deafening indictment. It is time to rediscover the vital role of the prophet, not as a figure of fear or suspicion, but as a cherished and necessary voice within the vibrant chorus of the Spirit. Let us cultivate a culture that welcomes the challenging yet ultimately life-giving word of the Lord spoken through His chosen messengers. Let the four hundred and eighty echoes of biblical prophecy awaken us from our slumber and empower us to embrace the fullness of the gifts Christ has so generously bestowed upon His Church. The time for the scandalous silence to end is now. The body of Christ, and indeed the world, desperately needs to hear the authentic voice of the modern-day prophet.

Call to Action

  • Re-educate on Biblical Prophecy: Dedicate time to studying the biblical understanding of the prophetic office, its function, and its importance throughout Scripture.
  • Cultivate Discernment: Develop and implement processes for discerning genuine prophetic gifts from false claims, emphasizing accountability and alignment with Scripture.
  • Create Space for Prophetic Voices: Intentionally create platforms within church settings for individuals with discerned prophetic gifts to share and be heard in appropriate and constructive ways.
  • Foster a Culture of Openness: Encourage a church culture that is open to receiving challenging words and perspectives, understanding that growth often comes through discomfort.
  • Integrate Prophetic Ministry: Actively seek to integrate prophetic insight into church leadership, decision-making, and strategic planning, alongside pastoral care and teaching.
  • Equip Leaders for Prophetic Engagement: Provide training and resources for pastors and church leaders on how to understand, interact with, and shepherd those with prophetic gifts.
  • Value Diverse Gifts Equally: Consciously work to value and celebrate all the gifts listed in Ephesians 4:11, recognizing their interdependence and unique contributions to the body of Christ.
  • Pray for the Spirit of Prophecy: Intentionally pray for the outpouring of the Holy Spirit and the raising up of authentic prophetic voices within the church today.
  • Challenge Consumeristic Models: Resist the temptation to prioritize comfort and ease over the challenging and transformative nature of genuine prophetic utterance.
  • Embrace the Uncomfortable Truths: Be willing to confront personal and corporate blind spots and injustices that prophetic voices may illuminate, responding with humility and a desire for change.”

Lastly, I am available to come to your church to participate in an open dialog regarding the place of the prophetic in the context of mature pastoral leadership. Before moving into the prophetic I pastored for over 20 years and thus I have a deep understanding of the problems and the potential of the prophetic. Pastor, let me help you. You won’t be disappointed in the growth and enrichment your congregation will experience as a result. Contact my office at 417-593-9802. ~ Prophet Russ


Discover more from Fathers Heart Ministry

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Add feedback

Leave Your Feedback

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.