As a Christian, Should You Go to an Atheist

Father’s Heart Ministry Presents

As a Christian, Should You Go to an Atheist for Counsel?

The answer is no, and the history of psychology shows why.

Prophet Russell Walden • November 10, 2026

 

Did you know that 73% of psychiatrists and psychologists are avowed atheists? Psalm 1 tells us not to seek the counsel of the ungodly, and an atheist is the very definition of ungodliness. On top of that, many of the most influential practitioners died by suicide. Something about the character of these mind sciences affects the suicide rate in ranks.

A U.S. review of health-professional deaths through 2018 ranked psychiatrists highest among ten health professions, ahead of other physicians. From 1960 to 1969, female psychologists were about three times the female population rate. Overall statistics show these professionals ranked fourth among those ten professions,

Psychology and psychiatry have pervaded the church world as well as the secular world, seemingly with no regard for the unavoidable dissonance between atheists and people of faith. What are you doing leaning on these? Listen, when your marriage is breaking, your mind is heavy, or your future looks foggy, whose voice are you going to let shape you? That is what counsel really is. It is not a casual chat. It is a person handing you a way of seeing yourself, your pain, and your God.

So let’s ask the question plainly: as a Christian, should you go to an atheist for counsel? The answer is no. That is not an insult to anyone’s intelligence or kindness. It is a matter of foundation. Counsel always flows from a worldview, and an atheist’s worldview has no room for the One who made you.

01   The Word

Scripture Already Answered This

The very first Psalm opens with a blessing and a boundary:

Blessed is the man that walketh not in the counsel of the ungodly, nor standeth in the way of sinners, nor sitteth in the seat of the scornful.

— Psalm 1:1 (KJV)

“Ungodly” simply means without God. It does not mean evil, stupid, or cruel. Plenty of people without God are bright, warm, and well-meaning. The warning is about whose counsel becomes your counsel. Notice the progression: walking, then standing, then sitting. You do not wake up one day in the seat of the scornful. You get there one “helpful session” at a time.

Then there is the root of the whole matter:

The fear of the LORD is the beginning of knowledge: but fools despise wisdom and instruction.

— Proverbs 1:7 (KJV)

If the fear of the Lord is where knowledge begins, then a counselor who starts without Him has started in the wrong place. He may collect true observations along the way, but he cannot reach the true diagnosis. The apostle Paul explains why:

But the natural man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God: for they are foolishness unto him: neither can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned.

— 1 Corinthians 2:14 (KJV)

Much of what troubles a believer, such as guilt, forgiveness, spiritual warfare, calling, and identity in Christ, is spiritually discerned. An atheist counselor is not being stubborn when he misses it. He is simply working with the wrong instruments.

02   The Record

Who Built Modern Psychology and Psychiatry?

Most Christians who walk into a counselor’s office never ask where the profession came from. They should. Modern psychology and psychiatry did not descend from the Church. They were built, in large part, by men who set God aside, and in several famous cases, men who walked away from the faith they were raised in.

Here is a short list of some of the most influential names in the field:

Pioneer Known For Relationship to Faith
Sigmund Freud Founder of psychoanalysis Declared himself an unbeliever and wrote The Future of an Illusion (1927), treating belief in God as an illusion born of wish and fear.
B. F. Skinner Behaviorism Raised in a Presbyterian home, left that faith, and taught that human behavior is shaped by environment, not by a soul answerable to God.
Albert Ellis Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy A committed atheist who argued in print that devout religious belief is tied to emotional disturbance.
Carl Rogers Person-centered therapy Studied at Union Theological Seminary, then left the ministry track and the orthodox faith of his upbringing. His therapy trusts the goodness of the self instead of calling it to repentance.

Not every figure in the field was a hostile atheist, and I am not claiming they were. Some were raised religious and drifted. Some kept a vague spirituality. A few, such as Viktor Frankl, held genuine faith. But the pattern is hard to miss: the dominant schools that built modern counseling began with man at the center and God at the edge, or off the page altogether.

The numbers back this up. As far back as the early 1900s, researcher James Leuba surveyed scientists on belief in God. Psychologists scored the lowest of every group, with only about 24 percent saying they believed. In 1969, a study of clinical psychologists in three major American cities found that roughly 40 percent called themselves atheist, agnostic, or had no religious position, while about 94 percent of Americans identified as Protestant, Catholic, or Jewish. A survey of American Psychological Association members in 1992 again found religious involvement far below that of the general public. What the research does show consistently is that the people who shape this profession are far less likely to believe in God than the people they counsel. That should give a believer pause.

03   The Problem

Different Foundation, Different Gospel

One might argue that their psychologist is a person of faith. Be that as it may the inherent nature of the discipline itself is athiest in nature and its foundation. So why would a Christian therapist or otherwise go to a discipline rooted in rejection of belief in God? It’s like asking a prostitute to lecture a group of young girls on chastity and morality.

Because every counselor has to answer a few questions before he opens his mouth. What is a human being? What is wrong with us? What does healing look like? What is the goal of life?

An atheist has to answer those without God. So the human being is an accident of biology. The problem is dysfunction, trauma, or bad programming, never sin. Healing is self-acceptance and self-actualization. The goal is to feel better and live authentically. Notice what is missing: repentance, forgiveness, deliverance, the renewing of the mind, and the call to become like Christ.

There is a way which seemeth right unto a man, but the end thereof are the ways of death.

— Proverbs 14:12 (KJV)

A lot of secular counsel “seems right.” It is calm, affirming, and often well-delivered. But if it tells you your answer is inside you, that your guilt is a hang-up to be managed instead of a debt Christ already paid, or that your convictions are the real problem, it is steering you off the road while smiling at you.

Beware lest any man spoil you through philosophy and vain deceit, after the tradition of men, after the rudiments of the world, and not after Christ.

— Colossians 2:8 (KJV)

Paul did not say philosophy is always false in every detail. He said it can spoil you, carry you off like plunder, when it is “not after Christ.” Counsel that is not after Christ is a risk to the believer, however polished the office or impressive the degree.

04   The Balance

What About Doctors and Real Emergencies?

Let me be careful here, because wisdom is not extremism. Going to an atheist for counsel about your soul, your marriage, your identity, your purpose, your morality, or your walk with God is one thing. Seeing a physician about a medical condition is another.

If you need a surgeon, an endocrinologist, a dentist, or a neurologist, find the most skilled one you can. Skill in setting a bone does not depend on the doctor’s theology. If you are in crisis, or you are afraid you might hurt yourself or someone else, do not wait for the perfect Christian counselor. Call 988 in the United States, or go to the nearest emergency room, and then bring your pastor and trusted believers around you.

The line is simple. Medicine treats the body. Counsel shapes the soul. The first can be received from many hands. The second must be placed only in hands that bow to Jesus Christ.

05   The Answer

Where a Believer Should Go Instead

God did not leave His children without counsel. He supplied it at every level:

  • The Wonderful Counsellor. Isaiah 9:6 names Jesus as Wonderful, Counsellor. He is not a distant figure. He is available to you today.
  • The Holy Spirit. Jesus promised a Comforter who would teach you all things (John 14:26). He knows you better than any therapist ever could.
  • The Word of God. The psalmist said, “Thy testimonies also are my delight and my counsellors” (Psalm 119:24). Scripture is not a last resort. It is a counselor.
  • Godly, mature people. Proverbs 11:14 says “in the multitude of counsellors there is safety.” Notice it does not say any multitude. Seek pastors, mentors, and believers whose lives and doctrine line up with Scripture.

 

There is no shortage of help for a believer who is willing to look for it in the right place. If you have been sitting under counsel that never mentions Christ, do not panic and do not be ashamed. Just redirect. Take what is true and useful, filter it through the Word, and lay the rest down.

✦ Reflect and Respond

Ask yourself: Whose counsel is shaping my thinking right now? Does it begin with the fear of the Lord? Have I been trading the voice of the Holy Spirit for the voice of someone who does not know Him?

Declare: Lord Jesus, You are my Wonderful Counsellor. I will not walk in the counsel of the ungodly. I choose the fear of the Lord as the beginning of my wisdom. Holy Spirit, teach me, lead me, and bring godly people around me who will speak Your truth in love. In Jesus’ name, amen.

 


Discover more from Fathers Heart Ministry

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Add feedback

Prophets and Prophecy Must be Judged. Please leave your response. Thank You.